Friday, April 22, 2022

The issue of race in the works of bell hooks and Luther Standing Bear

 

Gloria Jean Watkins, also known by her pen name Bell Hooks, is a social activist, feminist, professor, and author. She borrowed her pen name from her maternal great-grandmother, Bell Blair Hooks, because she was an individual that was never afraid to speak out and the result was that she was greatly admired. Hooks was born in 1952 in Hopkinsville, Kentucky to working class parents.[1] Hopkinsville was a segregated town and from the beginning of her life, Hooks had to go to public schools which were also segregated. Furthermore, as an avid reader in an environment of segregation, she ended up writing concerning the considerable adversities that she had to endure especially when she had to make a transition to an integrated school, where the majority of students and teachers were white; a scenario that was quite new to her. However, following her education, she began her career in 1976 at the University of Southern California where she was an English professor and senior lecturer in Ethnic Studies.[2] It was during her three years at this institution that she ended up having her first published work, And There We Wept in 1978.[3] The major focus of her writings has been on capitalism, gender, and race and the manner through which these have been prominent in the perpetuation of class domination and oppression in society. She is an individual that has not only published numerous books, but also participated in public lectures as well as documentary films. Thus, Hooks is therefore an individual that, through her works, has been able to undertake the task of addressing such issues as sexuality, mass media, history, art, and feminism.

One of Bell Hooks’ most notable works is Touching the Earth, which makes an attempt to show the way that the African American people are connected to the earth. She promotes the idea that African Americans should undertake to ensure that they reclaim the spiritual legacy in such a way that they end up connecting their personal wellbeing to that of the earth.[4] Furthermore, she suggests that it is necessary for African Americans to recognize that the fight to save the environment and the fight against racism are actually competing concerns, especially when one considers that the agrarian South has a direct connection with racism. The importance of this factor cannot be underestimated because it shows the manner through which the African American singular focus on bringing an end to racism has created a situation where they are completely divorced from nature.[5] Hooks further considers the way that their living close to nature has a beneficial effect on African Americans because they were able to attain a spirit of wonder that advocated for a reverence of life. However, because of their desire to escape the racial injustice that was prevalent in the South, they moved to the cities of the North, which resulted in the loss of connection with the agrarian South. In this way, rather than being connected to nature, they missed the entire connection to such an extent that they were forced to become what they were not. The sensual beauty of the South was gone, replaced by the divorce from community that is a constant feature of life in cities.[6] Thus, Hooks makes the connection between nature and race and considers the human divorce from nature to be the cause of racism.

In the essays Indian Wisdom by Luther Sanding Bear and Bell Hooks’ Touching the Earth, there are two sections in the former and one in the latter. These sections address the various concerns that the authors seek to bring to public notice. The first section in Indian Wisdom is one that seeks to address the matter of nature and the manner through which it was one of the mainstays of Native American society because of the close connection that they had to nature.[7] The second section makes an analysis of Native American religion and the way that it was an essential aspect of their lives based on not only their close connection to nature, but also the way that they did not fear nature. The section in Touching the Earth, on the other hand, addresses the connection between black people and the land and the way that because of this connection, they essentially lost their humanity when the moved away from the rural South to the urban North.

A number of shared themes are found in both Indian Wisdom and Touching the Earth. One of the most significant of these is the connection between humans and nature. This connection is seen in page 202 by the way that Standing Bear addresses the way that the Native Americans, specifically the Lakota, were very connected to nature to the extent of their being referred to as naturalists.[8] In page 363, Hooks also addresses the connection to nature, stating that by loving the earth, humans are able to love themselves. Another theme that is brought to the fore is that of the attempt to tame nature.[9] This is seen through the way that Standing Bear in page 205 shows the attempts by the white man to tame nature, and Hooks’ in page 365 who addresses the way that African Americans migrated from the rural South to the industrialized North.[10] Also, the theme of racism comes to the fore, as seen through the way that Native Americans are viewed as savages in page 205 of Indian Wisdom and the matter of racial harassment that black people encountered in the South as seen in page 366 of Hooks’ Touching the Earth.[11] The theme of spirituality and religion is also pertinent in Indian Wisdom page 206 and Touching the Earth page 365, which are addressed through the concern about the connection between spirituality and nature. Conservation is another theme that is common in both essays, and they each address the manner through which nature should be allowed to remain as it is for the welfare of all individuals. Finally, the theme of fear is also prominent, as seen through the way that Standing Bear, in page 205, seeks to promote the idea that white people are afraid of nature and this is the reason why the seek to tame it, and the fear of being out of place due to alienation of nature in page 365 of Hooks’ Touching the Earth.[12]



[1] "Bell Hooks Biography," Encyclopedia of World Biographies, https://www.notablebiographies.com/He-Ho/Hooks-Bell.html.

[2] Gary L Anderson and Kathryn G Herr, Encyclopedia of Activism and Social Justice (Sage Publications, 2007), 706.

[3] "Bell Hooks Speaks Up," The Sandspur, https://issuu.com/thesandspur/docs/112-17.

[4] Bell Hooks, "Touching the Earth," At Home on the Earth: Becoming  (2010): 364.

[5] Mayumi Toyosato, "Living in Place as African American Tradition: Inhabitory Consciousness in Her Own Place,"  (2004): 28.

[6] Peter HH Kahn Jr and Batya Friedman, "On Nature and Environmental Education: Black Parents Speak from the Inner City," Environmental Education Research 4, no. 1 (1998): 36.

[7] Chief Luther Standing Bear, "Indian Wisdom (1933)," The Great New Wilderness Debate  (1998): 202.

[8] Ibid.

[9] Hooks,  363.

[10] Ibid., 365; Bear,  205.

[11] 205; Hooks,  366.

[12] 365; Bear,  205.

No comments:

Post a Comment